Home Depot topped Wall Street’s forecasts on Tuesday, raised its sales outlook and named its finance chief as the next CEO. The stock fell anyway. The reason is a good lesson in how to read a retailer’s report: what matters is not just how much more it sold, but how it sold it and how much of each extra dollar it kept.
By Chief Editor Clark · The Market MBA · Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026
What happened
Home Depot (HD), the world’s largest home improvement retailer, reported its fiscal third quarter before the bell on Nov. 17. According to the company release and CNBC, which cited LSEG analyst estimates:
| Measure | Q3 fiscal 2026 | Wall Street expected | A year ago |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sales | $43.4 billion (+4.9%) | $42.8 billion | $41.4 billion |
| Adjusted earnings per share | $3.86 (+3.2%) | $3.84 | $3.74 |
| Comparable sales | +2.2% | +1.8% (StreetAccount) | n/a |
| Net earnings | $3.7 billion, $3.72 a share | n/a | $3.6 billion, $3.62 a share |
The company also named Chief Financial Officer Richard McPhail as CEO, effective next week. He replaces Ted Decker, CEO since 2022, who had been on medical leave since August, has returned, and will stay on as board chair. Ann-Marie Campbell becomes president and chief operating officer, and Jordan Broggi becomes CFO. “We’re not going to change course,” McPhail told CNBC.
Shares fell more than 3% after the report, CNBC said. That is the puzzle this lesson solves: a beat, a raised sales forecast and an orderly succession, yet a lower stock.
Lesson 1: Total sales vs. comparable sales
Sales grew 4.9%, but comparable sales (“comps”) grew only 2.2%. Comps measure sales at stores and businesses that have been open for at least a year, so they strip out growth that comes from simply getting bigger. They are the cleanest read on whether existing customers are spending more.
The gap between the two numbers is growth Home Depot bought or built. On the earnings call, McPhail said the full-year sales forecast reflects comps plus “the contribution of the GMS acquisition, new stores, new branches, and tuck-in acquisitions.” GMS is a building-products distributor that, like SRS, sells to professional contractors. Home Depot opened eight net new stores in the quarter and now has 2,372 stores plus more than 1,320 SRS locations.
The takeaway: when a company is making acquisitions, headline sales growth flatters the core business. Comps tell you what the existing machine is doing, and here it was a solid 2.2%, which the company described as its strongest comp growth in four years.
Lesson 2: Comps = ticket × traffic
A retailer can lift comps in two ways: more customer visits (transactions, or “traffic”) or more spent per visit (average ticket). Merchandising chief Billy Bastek gave the split on the call:
- Average ticket: up 3%.
- Comp transactions: down 0.5%.
- Big-ticket transactions (purchases over $1,000): up 4.5%.
Multiply them and you get roughly the comp: 1.03 × 0.995 ≈ 1.025, or about 2.5%. It won’t tie exactly to the reported 2.2%, because both inputs are rounded and the company defines its own comp measures, but the shape is clear: fewer trips, bigger baskets.
Now ask why the basket got bigger. Asked about ticket growth, Bastek said about half of the increase came from inflation, and the rest from mix and new products. So roughly half of that 3% ticket gain was higher prices, not more stuff. Price-driven growth is real revenue, but it also tends to come with higher costs, which leads to the next lesson.
One more detail worth noting: comps peaked mid-quarter. Total comps ran +1.1% in August, +3.8% in September and +1.8% in October. On the call, a UBS analyst linked the October cool-down to a spike in mortgage rates during the quarter. McPhail didn’t blame rates directly; he said “housing turnover hasn’t moved in four years” and that the company’s growth is coming from taking market share.
Lesson 3: Where the extra dollars went (margins)
Here is why the stock slipped. Sales rose $2.0 billion, but profit didn’t keep pace:
| Line | Q3 2026 | Q3 2025 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gross margin (profit after cost of goods) | 32.8% | about 33.4% | down about 60 basis points |
| Operating expense (% of sales) | 20.1% | about 20.4% | down about 30 basis points |
| Operating margin | 12.6% | 12.9% | down 30 basis points |
| Adjusted operating margin | 13.0% | 13.3% | down 30 basis points |
A basis point is one-hundredth of a percentage point, so 60 basis points is 0.6 points. That sounds tiny, but on $43.4 billion of sales, 0.6% of sales is about $260 million of gross profit the company would have kept at last year’s margin. McPhail blamed “a rising cost environment as well as a change in mix as a result of acquisitions”: the pro distribution businesses Home Depot bought earn thinner margins than its stores.
Put the pieces together using the reported margins. Operating profit was about $5.47 billion (12.6% of $43.4 billion) vs. about $5.34 billion a year ago (12.9% of $41.4 billion), growth of roughly 2.4%, about half the pace of sales. Adjusted EPS grew 3.2%, a bit faster than that, helped partly by interest and other expense falling $68 million to $528 million. (These operating-profit figures are our estimates from the rounded margins the company reported.)
The takeaway: “sales beat” and “profit beat” are different things. Home Depot beat revenue estimates by about $600 million but EPS by just 2 cents. When sales outrun profit, look at gross margin first.
Lesson 4: Read the guidance like a trader
Home Depot updated its full-year outlook. Compare the new numbers with the old ranges (prior ranges per CNBC):
| Fiscal 2026 forecast | Before | Now |
|---|---|---|
| Total sales growth | range topped out near 4.5% | about 4.5% (top end) |
| Comparable sales growth | flat to +2% | about +1.4% |
| Adjusted EPS growth (from $14.69) | flat to +4% | about +2% |
| Adjusted operating margin | n/a | about 12.8% |
| Gross margin | n/a | about 33.0% |
Sales moved to the top of the range, but the EPS forecast landed right at the midpoint of the old range (+2%, about $14.98 a share). In other words, the company expects to sell more than it planned and earn about what it planned. McPhail told analysts the company had adjusted margin guidance “from the midpoint of our original guidance range by 10 basis points” to reflect product and acquisition mix.
When a company raises sales but not profit, investors read it as margin pressure, and that is what the market priced on Tuesday.
Lesson 5: What a CFO-to-CEO handoff signals
Succession news can rattle a stock when it is sudden or unexplained. This one looks planned: Decker called it “the next phase of our succession plan,” McPhail has been at the company since 2005, and Decker stays as chair. A finance chief stepping up usually signals continuity, with a focus on capital allocation and margins, rather than a strategy reset. McPhail said the company will keep leaning into professional customers and AI tools. Investors still have to judge the new team by results, starting with the fourth quarter.
What to watch next
- Gross margin in Q4. Guidance implies about 33.0% for the year. Watch whether acquisition mix keeps pulling it lower into 2027, which a UBS analyst raised on the call.
- Mortgage rates and the Fed. Markets price a 97.4% chance of a December quarter-point Fed rate hike, according to CME FedWatch data cited by Reuters. Higher rates keep housing turnover, a key driver of big remodels, frozen.
- Traffic. Transactions fell 0.5% while ticket rose 3%. If inflation cools and ticket growth fades, comps need traffic to come back.
- The next report is in February, McPhail’s first full quarter as CEO.
Related lesson: How to read a company one segment at a time (Tyson).
Key terms
- Comparable sales (comps): sales growth at locations open at least a year; removes the effect of new stores and acquisitions.
- Average ticket: average amount spent per transaction.
- Transactions (traffic): number of customer purchases.
- Gross margin: sales minus the cost of the goods sold, as a % of sales.
- Basis point: 0.01 percentage point; 60 basis points = 0.6 points.
- Adjusted EPS: earnings per share excluding certain items (here, intangible-asset amortization from acquisitions).
Sources
- The Home Depot: Third Quarter Fiscal 2026 results and updated guidance (Nov. 17, 2026)
- CNBC: Home Depot names Richard McPhail as new CEO, beats earnings expectations
- Investing.com: Home Depot Q3 2026 earnings call transcript
- Investing.com: Premarket movers, Nov. 17, 2026
- Reuters via Investing.com: US stock futures slip ahead of Nvidia results
This article is for education only and is not financial advice. Figures are from the company and the sources linked above; percentage changes are rounded.
For education and entertainment only. Not financial advice.

